The Second Circuit Court of Appeals on November 10 vacated the district court's dismissal of Second Amendment challenges to New York City's one-firearm-at-a-time carry limit and its 90-day handgun purchase restriction, ordering those claims back to the district court for evaluation under the historical tradition test the Supreme Court set out in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen. The case is Mills v. New York City, No. 24-3308.

Judge Reena Raggi wrote the unanimous opinion for a panel that also included Judges Livingston and Park. Raggi also wrote for a prior Second Circuit panel on the broader Bruen remand of New York's statewide carry statute, and her framing here tracks the same methodology: when a firearm regulation faces a Second Amendment challenge, the government bears the burden of identifying historical analogues from the founding era that show the restriction is consistent with this nation's tradition of firearm regulation. The district court had dismissed the challenges on other grounds without conducting that historical analysis, and the Second Circuit said that was error.

The ruling does not strike down either active rule and explicitly declined to decide whether they are "necessarily unconstitutional." What it does require is that New York City defend the one-gun carry limit and the 90-day purchase restriction before Judge Jed Rakoff of the Southern District of New York — a burden the city did not meet at the initial stage.

A since-repealed two-gun carry license cap was also named in the suit. The plaintiffs argued the repeal did not moot their claims because fees and administrative burdens tied to the now-defunct rule remained live issues. The Second Circuit rejected that argument and affirmed dismissal of the repeal-related claims, narrowing the live dispute to the two active restrictions.

The Second Circuit has worked through layers of New York City and New York State carry restrictions since Bruen, with mixed results. In earlier cases the circuit upheld some sensitive-locations provisions while striking others as insufficiently grounded in founding-era history. The Mills remand adds the one-gun limit — a restriction with few, if any, direct analogues in American firearms law — to the list of regulations Rakoff must now examine on historical grounds. Pro-Second Amendment legal groups including the Second Amendment Foundation and Firearms Policy Coalition have been active in related Second Circuit litigation, though their role in this particular case was not immediately confirmed.

If Rakoff finds no sufficient historical support for the one-gun carry limit or the 90-day rule, the city could appeal to the same Second Circuit, seek en banc rehearing, or modify the challenged restrictions. The practical stakes are significant: tens of thousands of active permit holders in the five boroughs are currently limited to carrying a single firearm, and the 90-day restriction affects the pace at which lawful buyers can acquire handguns in one of the country's largest cities. No scheduling order from the district court has been issued.